"Adapting for a Local Space Can be Tricky": Designing Units for Teachers to Localize Through Phenomenon Adaptation
Document Type
Article
Publication Date
5-2-2025
Abstract
Learning science in the context of local phenomena and problems can be powerful for young people. Yet, designing place-based instructional materials is resource intensive, limiting broad access. This study investigates how instructional materials designed for widespread use can support teacher localization through phenomenon adaptation, whereby teachers add or swap phenomena relevant to students' interests, identities, and community. Using design-based research, we developed two upper elementary storyline units and professional learning to support teachers' pedagogical design capacity for phenomenon adaptation. We studied 12 teachers' adaptations during their first implementation of the units by analyzing teachers' interviews, reflections, and professional learning discussions. Findings from both units showed that all teachers added phenomena, with common adaptations including adding student-generated phenomena. In the unit anchored around one phenomenon, teachers extended exploration of existing phenomena, citing student interest and cross-curricular connections as rationale. In the unit motivated by multiple phenomena, teachers added new phenomena to support knowledge building and connect to students' lived experiences. Embedded curricular resources offered low-floor entry points for teachers new to the unit. Supplementary resources showed potential as high-ceiling options for more experienced teachers. Phenomenon adaptation requires teachers to coordinate their knowledge of curriculum, students, and community resources to incorporate meaningful phenomena while maintaining coherence. Challenges included time constraints, high quality of existing materials, limited knowledge of local phenomena, and limited confidence. Implications for curriculum and professional learning are discussed, highlighting the potential to turn curricula designed for widespread use into locally-relevant learning experiences.
Source Publication
Science Education (ISSN 0036-8326 | eISSN 1098-237X)
Recommended Citation
Harris, E. M., Mohan, L., Hanson, A. A., Whitt, K. A. C., Guy‐Gaytán, C., & Kenyon, L. O. (2025). “Adapting for a local space can be tricky”: Designing units for teachers to localize through phenomenon adaptation. Science Education, sce.21978. https://doi.org/10.1002/sce.21978
Comments
The "Link to Full Text" on this page opens the full article [HTML] at the publisher website, including Supplemental Materials. A PDF is also available at that location.
This is an Open Access article published by Wiley and distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives License, which permits non-commercial re-use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited, and is not altered, transformed, or built upon in any way. CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
This article was published online by Wiley in May 2025 as an article of Science Education, ahead of inclusion in an issue of that journal.
Author note: Lisa Kenyon is the Director of AFIT's Center for Innovative Education (CIE).